Ronald Huereca is part developer, part mammal. And he only comes out at night. View the author's website.
 

Does the Intention Behind Appreciation Really Matter?

I am a firm believer that a lot of reader appreciation techniques can translate directly from the offline world.

As food for thought, I thought I’d present some offline examples of when I was trying to use appreciation techniques and my intentions were questioned. As a result, I never visited the places again.

Getting a Meal

When I was seventeen years old, I worked at a small grocery store as a bagger in a rural town. One lady always bought a large load of groceries and most of the other carry-out people were reluctant to bag her groceries. I took on the challenge and developed a casual talking relationship with the lady every time she came in.

One day she expressed that she had gotten a new job at a local restaurant. I told her I’d stop in and order something and say hello, which she seemed fine with at the time.

When I showed up, she had a concerned look on her face and sat down briefly at my booth.

“My husband is concerned why a seventeen year old kid is expressing interest in his wife. I just wanted to know what your intentions are for being here.”

I probably had a puzzled look on my face and I explained that I was just here to eat and support her at her new job since she always was so nice to me at the grocery store. I wasn’t pursuing a relationship with this obviously married and devoted woman.

I never went to the restaurant or spoke to the lady again.

Getting a Haircut

Here in my town I frequented a haircut place quite often because the lady who cut my hair was always really nice. For some reason I couldn’t write in my tip when I charged the purchase, so I always left her without a tip. And I felt bad about it because I consider myself a good tipper.

So one day she tells me a story about how she wrecked her car and how her husband had also been in a minor accident. I felt bad about it and since I had never given her a tip for the three or so haircuts she had given me, I walked to a nearby Chili’s and bought her a gift card. I brought it back and she was very thankful.

When I returned for my next haircut, I could tell she was a little uneasy. I asked her a few questions about her husband and if she had gotten a new vehicle since the last time I talked to her she was just in an accident.

Then she asked me, “So, how much out of your way is this place?”

I didn’t understand the question. Sure, the haircut place was a little out of my way, but it depended on which way I was going.

So I responded, “Well, not too much out of the way since I live nowhere close to a haircut place.”

“Oh.” She replied, “Because the gift you gave me last time was a bit much.”

I tried to cut the awkwardness, “Well, I never carry cash on me and I took the gift card as making up for lost tips. I apologize.”

That was the last haircut I got at the haircut place.

Conclusion

In both situations, my intentions were good. I was trying to show appreciation and customer service, but my intentions were unfairly questioned. As a result, I never visited the establishments again.

You’ll never know the “true” intentions of appreciation, so in some situations, it is better to take the appreciation rather than question why you are the recipient.

Read the Discussion (3 Responses)

  • Andrew says...

    http://www.arickmann.co.uk

    I would say both yes, and no.

    There is always an ulterior motive, whether conscious or not, so we just have to decide which motives we consider to be valid and which not.

    I think it depends on where your focus is.

    Being nice to someone brings you satisfaction, it helps build platonic relationships that may well be of benefit at some point; however, these things do not involve the recipient of the kindness giving anything away and it involves appreciating that person for themselves, not for what they can bring to you.

    Being nice to someone because they could get you a job, or click a link, or other ‘favours’ focusses not on the person but on you, on what you want, and very often this means that the person themselves are largely incidental.

    That is where the problem arises. If someone thinks you are trying to manipulate them into an action, or will only be interested if they undertake that action, then they don’t really think they appreciate you, and they might be right.

  • Post Author

    Ronald Huereca says...

    http://www.ronalfy.com

    You make a good point Andrew. Sometimes the intentions do matter. In the examples above, if I were pursuing a relationship beyond casual friendship, I would have been in the wrong with my intentions.

    My goal with a lot of things (when going to restaurants and such) is to develop a working/casual relationship with whomever I am interacting. For example, I frequent a particular Mexican restaurant because I have become friends with the owner and staff. If actually make a conscious decision when I go out: do I want to support a chain restaurant, or my friends? In most cases, I’d rather go to the place where I’m known and respected and not treated as just another customer with a credit card.

  • Simonne says...

    http://www.alltipsandtricks.com

    Of course the intention matters. However, one should be careful when communicating his intentions, because as you just said, they can be easily misunderstood. Many people, maybe because of the abuses they’ve been victims, cannot relax anymore, thus being very skeptical with all people who might want to get too close. If your belief is that all people are presumtively bad, and you see somebody giving you a favor which you think you don’t deserve, then you ask yourself about that person’s intentions, so you end up by being rude.

Join the Discussion